Rope (1948)
IMDb Listing
I hadn’t seen Rope in nearly a decade and a half, and I’ve always held it in relatively low esteem. Hitchcock filmed it in a series of long takes, often with edits disguised to make them look even longer than they were, and accordingly the movie has a reputation as something of a technical gimmick. I believe even Hitchcock himself dismissed it along those lines. But watching it again, I was surprised to find it more enjoyable than I remembered. It’s a story about two college classmates who murder an acquaintance, and then hold a dinner party with friends with the corpse hidden in the room, all as a sort of intellectual game. Hitch’s experiment with long takes doesn’t really pay off, but it doesn’t hold the movie back much, either. Occasionally it feels like the camera isn’t really where it should be, especially when it’s moving (such as when it follows characters down a hallway), but I doubt many casual viewers will notice or care; for the most part I didn’t. Otherwise, the movie is pretty strong with its characters, who are not aware of the circumstances but are given mostly sympathetic treatment, all things considered. James Stewart’s character is even pretty interesting, at least until a final act speech that just about unravels the movie. It’s a major flaw, but story-wise the movie is fairly strong up to that point. I still think the movie’s worth watching as a curiosity, in terms of both the technical aspects and an interesting story that almost works. 7/10
December 31, 2011 Posted by Brian | Hitchcock, Alfred | Leave a comment
About
Short reviews of films, organized by director. Every film is given a rating, with 10 being the highest. For further information/credits of the films reviewed, the IMDb link is provided.
An explanation of the scale:
10: Highest recommendation; masterpiece
9: A great film
8: Uncommonly good
7: Worthwhile
6: Really just OK
5: Ambivalent or indifferent
4: Can’t recommend
3: Few redeeming qualities
2: Wholly inept
1: Aggressively awful
Categories
- *Highest recommendations* (108)
- Abrams, J.J. (2)
- Affleck, Ben (2)
- Akin, Fatih (1)
- Aldrich, Robert (1)
- Aleksandrov, Grigori (1)
- Alfredson, Daniel (2)
- Alfredson, Tomas (1)
- Allen, Lewis (1)
- Allen, Woody (3)
- Almodóvar, Pedro (4)
- Altman, Robert (3)
- Amenábar, Alejandro (1)
- Anderson, Lindsay (1)
- Anderson, Paul Thomas (3)
- Anderson, Wes (6)
- Andrews, Mark (1)
- Antonioni, Michelangelo (1)
- Arnold, Andrea (2)
- Aronofsky, Darren (3)
- Arteta, Miguel (2)
- Ashby, Hal (1)
- Assayas, Olivier (4)
- Audiard, Jacques (3)
- Baker, Roy (1)
- Banksy (1)
- Batmanglij, Zal (2)
- Baumbach, Noah (2)
- Bayona, J.A. (2)
- Beauvois, Xavier (1)
- Beineix, Jean-Jacques (1)
- Bergman, Ingmar (3)
- Bertolucci, Bernardo (1)
- Bier, Susanne (1)
- Bigelow, Kathryn (2)
- Bird, Brad (3)
- Black, Shane (1)
- Blomkamp, Neill (1)
- Bobin, James (1)
- Boden, Anna (2)
- Bong Joon-ho (1)
- Boyle, Danny (3)
- Branagh, Kenneth (1)
- Bresson, Robert (8)
- Brooks, James L. (1)
- Brooks, Richard (1)
- Bruckman, Clyde (1)
- Buñuel, Luis (1)
- Burton, Tim (4)
- Cahill, Mike (1)
- Cameron, James (1)
- Campanella, Juan José (1)
- Campbell, Martin (2)
- Campion, Jane (1)
- Cantet, Laurent (2)
- Capotondi, Giuseppe (1)
- Capra, Frank (1)
- Carax, Leos (1)
- Carion, Christian (1)
- Cavalcanti, Alberto (1)
- Cavayé, Fred (1)
- Cedar, Joseph (1)
- Chabrol, Claude (2)
- Chandor, J.C. (1)
- Chaplin, Charles (8)
- Chapman, Brenda (1)
- Cholodenko, Lisa (1)
- Chomet, Sylvain (1)
- Cianfrance, Derek (2)
- Clément, René (1)
- Clooney, George (3)
- Clouzot, Henri-Georges (5)
- Cocteau, Jean (1)
- Coen, Ethan (5)
- Coen, Joel (12)
- Considine, Paddy (1)
- Cooper, Scott (1)
- Coppola, Francis Ford (4)
- Coppola, Sofia (3)
- Copti, Scandar (1)
- Corbijn, Anton (1)
- Cronenberg, David (3)
- Crowe, Cameron (3)
- Cuarón, Alfonso (1)
- Curran, John (1)
- Curtis, Simon (1)
- Curtiz, Michael (2)
- Daldry, Stephen (1)
- Daniels, Lee (1)
- Dardenne, Jean-Pierre and Luc (1)
- Dassin, Jules (2)
- Davies, Terence (1)
- Dayton, Jonathan (1)
- De Sica, Vittorio (1)
- Del Toro, Guillermo (4)
- Demme, Jonathan (1)
- Demy, Jacques (2)
- Denis, Claire (4)
- Desplechin, Arnaud (1)
- Dominik, Andrew (1)
- Donen, Stanley (1)
- Dumont, Bruno (1)
- Duplass, Jay (2)
- Duplass, Mark (2)
- Durkin, Sean (1)
- Eastwood, Clint (4)
- Edgerton, Nash (1)
- Egoyan, Atom (1)
- Eisenstein, Sergei M. (6)
- Ephron, Nora (1)
- Epstein, Rob (1)
- Errando, Tono (1)
- Farhadi, Asghar (2)
- Faris, Valerie (1)
- Farmiga, Vera (1)
- Fassbinder, Rainer Werner (1)
- Favreau, Jon (2)
- Fedorchenko, Aleksei (1)
- Fellini, Federico (1)
- Fiennes, Ralph (1)
- Fierlinger, Paul (1)
- Fierlinger, Sandra (1)
- Fincher, David (4)
- Fleck, Ryan (2)
- Fleming, Victor (2)
- Ford, John (4)
- Ford, Tom (1)
- Forster, Marc (4)
- Franju, Georges (1)
- Frears, Stephen (1)
- Fricke, Ron (1)
- Friedkin, William (2)
- Friedman, Jeffrey (1)
- Fuqua, Antoine (1)
- García, Rodrigo (2)
- Garrone, Matteo (1)
- Genz, Henrik Ruben (1)
- Gervasi, Sacha (1)
- Gibson, Mel (1)
- Gilliam, Terry (3)
- Gilroy, Tony (2)
- Gitai, Amos (1)
- Glodell, Evan (1)
- Godard, Jean-Luc (4)
- Goldberg, Evan (1)
- Gondry, Michel (3)
- González Iñárritu, Alejandro (1)
- Gordon, Seth (1)
- Goulding, Edmund (1)
- Granik, Debra (1)
- Greengrass, Paul (2)
- Guadagnino, Luca (1)
- Haggis, Paul (1)
- Hancock, John Lee (1)
- Haneke, Michael (3)
- Hansen-Løve, Mia (2)
- Hanson, Curtis (1)
- Harron, Mary (1)
- Hausner, Jessica (1)
- Hawks, Howard (4)
- Haynes, Todd (2)
- Hazanavicius, Michel (1)
- Heisenberg, Benjamin (1)
- Hellman, Monte (1)
- Herzog, Werner (3)
- Hillcoat, John (3)
- Hitchcock, Alfred (10)
- Hoffman, Michael (1)
- Holofcener, Nicole (1)
- Honoré, Christophe (2)
- Hooper, Tom (2)
- Hopper, Dennis (1)
- Howard, Ron (1)
- Hughes Brothers, The (1)
- Huston, John (4)
- Ichikawa, Kon (1)
- Imamura, Shohei (1)
- Ivory, James (2)
- Jackson, Peter (2)
- Jarrold, Julian (1)
- Jewison, Norman (1)
- Johnson, Rian (2)
- Johnston, Joe (2)
- Jones, Duncan (1)
- Jonze, Spike (3)
- Jordan, Neil (2)
- July, Miranda (1)
- Kaurismäki, Aki (1)
- Kazan, Elia (8)
- Keaton, Buster (2)
- Kechiche, Abdellatif (2)
- Keighley, William (1)
- Kelly, Gene (1)
- Kiarostami, Abbas (2)
- Kim Ki-duk (1)
- Kondracki, Larysa (1)
- Koppelman, Brian (1)
- Korine, Harmony (1)
- Kosashvili, Dover (1)
- Kubrick, Stanley (6)
- Kurosawa, Akira (11)
- Lang, Fritz (16)
- Lanthimos, Yorgos (1)
- Lasseter, John (5)
- Laughton, Charles (1)
- Lawrence, Francis (2)
- Lean, David (2)
- Lee Chang-dong (1)
- Lee, Ang (2)
- Lee, Spike (2)
- Leigh, Mike (1)
- Lerner, Irving (1)
- Leterrier, Louis (1)
- Levien, David (1)
- Levine, Jonathan (1)
- Levy, Shawn (1)
- Liman, Doug (1)
- Linklater, Richard (2)
- Lloyd, Phyllida (1)
- Loach, Ken (1)
- Loktev, Julia (1)
- Lubitsch, Ernst (1)
- Luhrmann, Baz (1)
- Lumet, Sidney (7)
- Lupino, Ida (1)
- Mackendrick, Alexander (1)
- Madden, John (1)
- Majewski, Lech (1)
- Malick, Terrence (5)
- Malle, Louis (1)
- Mangold, James (2)
- Mann, Anthony (1)
- Mann, Michael (5)
- Mariscal, Javier (1)
- Marsh, James (1)
- Marshall, Rob (1)
- McCarthy, Tom (1)
- McDonagh, John Michael (1)
- McKay, Adam (1)
- McQueen, Steve (3)
- Melville, Jean-Pierre (6)
- Mendes, Sam (1)
- Meyers, Nancy (1)
- Michôd, David (1)
- Michell, Roger (1)
- Miller, Bennett (1)
- Mills, Mike (1)
- Minghella, Anthony (1)
- Mitchell, John Cameron (1)
- Moore, Tomm (1)
- Morris, Errol (1)
- Moverman, Oren (2)
- Murnau, F.W. (1)
- Na Hong-Jin (1)
- Nettheim, Daniel (1)
- Newmeyer, Fred C (1)
- Nichols, Jeff (3)
- Nichols, Mike (1)
- Niles, Ben (1)
- Noé, Gaspar (1)
- Nolan, Christopher (8)
- Nolfi, George (1)
- Noyce, Phillip (1)
- O'Connor, Gavin (1)
- Obayashi, Nobuhiko (1)
- Ophüls, Max (1)
- Oplev, Niels Arden (1)
- Pabst, G.W. (1)
- Pakula, Alan J. (1)
- Park Chan-wook (1)
- Paronnaud, Vincent (2)
- Payne, Alexander (2)
- Peckinpah, Sam (2)
- Penn, Sean (1)
- Pennell, Eagle (1)
- Phillips, Todd (1)
- Polanski, Roman (8)
- Pollack, Sydney (1)
- Ponsoldt, James (1)
- Pontecorvo, Gillo (1)
- Porumboiu, Corneliu (1)
- Powell, Michael (5)
- Preminger, Otto (4)
- Pressburger, Emeric (4)
- Rafelson, Bob (1)
- Raimi, Sam (1)
- Ramsay, Lynne (1)
- Redford, Robert (2)
- Reed, Carol (4)
- Reeves, Matt (1)
- Reichardt, Kelly (1)
- Reitman, Jason (2)
- Renoir, Jean (3)
- Resnais, Alain (3)
- Reygadas, Carlos (1)
- Richet, Jean-François (2)
- Ritchie, Guy (2)
- Rivette, Jacques (2)
- Roach, Jay (1)
- Robbins, Tim (1)
- Robinson, Bruce (1)
- Roeg, Nicolas (1)
- Rogen, Seth (1)
- Romanek, Mark (1)
- Ross, Gary (1)
- Russell, David O. (4)
- Satrapi, Marjane (2)
- Sayles, John (2)
- Scanlon, Dan (1)
- Schnabel, Julian (2)
- Schneider, Aaron (1)
- Scorsese, Martin (14)
- Scott, Ridley (3)
- Sedgwick, Edward (1)
- Shani, Yaron (1)
- Sheridan, Jim (2)
- Shindo, Kaneto (4)
- Shyamalan, M. Night (1)
- Sigismondi, Floria (1)
- Siodmak, Robert (1)
- Smith, Chris (1)
- Snyder, Zack (1)
- Soderbergh, Steven (7)
- Sokurov, Alexander (1)
- Sonnenfeld, Barry (1)
- Spielberg, Steven (6)
- Spielmann, Götz (1)
- Stanton, Andrew (1)
- Stoller, Nicholas (1)
- Stone, Oliver (4)
- Sturges, Preston (1)
- Taccone, Jorma (1)
- Tarantino, Quentin (4)
- Tarkovsky, Andrei (7)
- Tarr, Béla (2)
- Tashlin, Frank (1)
- Tati, Jacques (2)
- Taylor, Sam (1)
- Taylor, Steve (1)
- Taylor, Tate (1)
- Taymor, Julie (1)
- Téchiné, André (3)
- Teems, Scott (1)
- Teshigahara, Hiroshi (1)
- To, Johnnie (1)
- Tourneur, Jacques (5)
- Trevorrow, Colin (1)
- Trueba, Fernando (1)
- Truffaut, François (8)
- Tucker, Anand (1)
- Tykwer, Tom (2)
- Unkrich, Lee (1)
- Vallée, Jean-Marc (1)
- Van Sant, Gus (3)
- Vasilyev, Dmitri (1)
- Vaughn, Matthew (2)
- Verbinski, Gore (1)
- Villeneuve, Denis (2)
- Virzì, Paolo (1)
- Visconti, Luchino (1)
- Vlácil, Frantisek (1)
- von Donnersmarck, Florian H. (1)
- von Trier, Lars (1)
- von Trotta, Margarethe (1)
- Wachowski, Andy (1)
- Wachowski, Lana (1)
- Wallace, Randall (1)
- Washington, Denzel (1)
- Webb, Marc (1)
- Weerasethakul, Apichatpong (1)
- Weitz, Chris (2)
- Weitz, Paul (1)
- Welles, Orson (3)
- Wellman, William A. (1)
- Wenders, Wim (1)
- Whedon, Joss (1)
- Wiene, Robert (1)
- Wilder, Billy (12)
- Winding Refn, Nicolas (2)
- Winterbottom, Michael (2)
- Wong Kar-Wai (5)
- Wright, Edgar (3)
- Wright, Joe (3)
- Wyatt, Rupert (1)
- Wyler, William (2)
- Yates, David (2)
- Young, Terence (1)
- Zeitlin, Benh (1)
- Zemeckis, Robert (3)
- Zhang Yimou (2)
- Zwick, Edward (1)
-
Recent Posts
Recent Comments
Archives
- May 2014
- April 2014
- March 2014
- January 2014
- December 2013
- November 2013
- October 2013
- September 2013
- August 2013
- July 2013
- June 2013
- May 2013
- April 2013
- March 2013
- February 2013
- January 2013
- December 2012
- November 2012
- October 2012
- September 2012
- August 2012
- July 2012
- June 2012
- May 2012
- April 2012
- March 2012
- February 2012
- January 2012
- December 2011
- November 2011
- October 2011
- September 2011
- August 2011
- July 2011
- June 2011
- May 2011
- April 2011
- March 2011
- February 2011
- January 2011
- December 2010
- November 2010
- October 2010
- September 2010
- August 2010
- July 2010
- June 2010
- May 2010
- April 2010
- March 2010
- February 2010
- January 2010
- June 2008